Forces Reunited
Current Members: 1,580,038  
 
 
    HOME    
FORCES WAR RECORDS
 FORCES SHOP 
FORCES DATING
FORCES DISCOUNTS

Community
  >> Search >> Home


You are not logged in. Click here to login or click here to register.

Turn off these pesky adverts! - What is this?

Forces Reunited - Merging of Regiments
www.forcesreunited.org.uk >> General >> Hot Topic >> Merging of Regiments
Forces Reunited Forums
>> Post New Topic
<< Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 [13] 14 15 Next >>
AuthorTopic
Murray Whyte
Add Forum Tag
Moderator





Membership Level: Full
Posts: 5496
Status: Offline
Don’t Fix What Ain’t Broke


John,

I take on board what you say, however, when it comes to the fighting spirit of soldiers, loyalty and trust are high on the agenda.

I am well aware of the meaning of loyalty and trust; this coupled with the strength of the traditional family links within a Scottish Regiment give the Scottish soldier something to live, fight and die for.

At present, the British Government is destroying all the great traditions of the Scottish Regiments (and probably the English ones as well).  Their proposals to merge two great Scottish Regiments into one and then form the rest into a super division are ill thought out.  

They seem to think that a move to smart weapons is the way forward.  I ask you, without soldiers on the ground, where will the Intel come from?  Who will verify targets for the smart bombs?

In the changing world today, there is still a need for the foot soldier.  Smart weapons cannot fight a war against terrorists or guerrillas.  The only way to combat this is by getting soldiers out on patrol in areas where T&G activity is suspected.

I could go on but I won’t.

Everyone is entitled to their opinion.

Murray


Last edited by Murray Whyte
Report Post
21/12/2005 19:21:32
                                                   >> Edit This Post >> Quote This Post
jack (jock) kelly
"DOON THE HATCH"





Membership Level: Full
Posts: 8146
Status: Offline
merging regiments


Quoting: Murray Whyte

John,

I take on board what you say, however, when it comes to the fighting spirit of soldiers, loyalty and trust are high on the agenda.

I am well aware of the meaning of loyalty and trust; this coupled with the strength of the traditional family links within a Scottish Regiment give the Scottish soldier something to live, fight and die for.

At present, the British Government is destroying all the great traditions of the Scottish Regiments (and probably the English ones as well).  Their proposals to merge two great Scottish Regiments into one and then form the rest into a super division are ill thought out.  

They seem to think that a move to smart weapons is the way forward.  I ask you, without soldiers on the ground, where will the Intel come from?  Who will verify targets for the smart bombs?

In the changing world today, there is still a need for the foot soldier.  Smart weapons cannot fight a war against terrorists or guerrillas.  The only way to combat this is by getting soldiers out on patrol in areas where T&G activity is suspected.

I could go on but I won’t.

Everyone is entitled to their opinion.

Murray


Last edited by Murray Whyte

very well put murray

View Attachment View Attachment

be happy lifes to short!(jacky)
Report Post
22/12/2005 09:23:43
                                                   >> Edit This Post >> Quote This Post
John Lennon
Add Forum Tag



Membership Level: Basic
Posts: 15
Status: Offline
Fighting Spirit/Loyalty

Hi Murray, I agree with you totally with what you say about the fighting spirit and loyalty of the soldier on the ground. I spent a number of good years with The Royal Highland Fusiliers and I found the comradeship and spirit second to none however I also found this wherever I served no matter weather it was a white hackle or red and white. I agree that no matter what the way forward is, this is something that can never be replaced by technoligy.
My daughter is away this week at Ballykinler on her winter training camp with her university OTC, one of the options she is interested in is Bomb Disposal amongst many things. We talk about her experiences and one of the things that stand out is that todays Army is not the Army I left just 10 years ago. Can you imagine some of the youngsters today lugging around a Charlie G or an 81 mm Mortar Base Plate. On a trip to Monti Cassino a few years ago I looked in awe at the target the allies were attacking and thanked god I didn’t have to go through that, especially with the equipment they had at the time.
I hope that I have not lost my way and that you understand what I am trying to say.

John

Last edited by John Lennon
Report Post
22/12/2005 10:07:11
                                                   >> Edit This Post >> Quote This Post
jim mahoney
Add Forum Tag



Membership Level: Basic
Posts: 679
Status: Offline
merging.

thank god they cant take our memories away from us,,[they might try that one day].
Report Post
22/12/2005 19:58:34
                                                   >> Edit This Post >> Quote This Post
Murray Whyte
Add Forum Tag
Moderator





Membership Level: Full
Posts: 5496
Status: Offline
Memories



Better start archiving them on DVDs so that the future generation can learn something about the fighting spirit of the UK Military.

Murray
Report Post
22/12/2005 20:40:09
                                                   >> Edit This Post >> Quote This Post
<< Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 [13] 14 15 Next >>
>> Reply To This Post
Moderated By: Murray Whyte, Edward Bishop,Bob Draper
Users Here: vicky codling nee bassett
REGISTER
LOGIN
FIND FRIENDS
MILITARY NEWS
CAMPAIGNS
REUNIONS
GALLERY
FORUMS
CHAT ROOM
REMEMBRANCE
HONOUR ROLL
TESTIMONIALS
MEMORIES
COMPETITIONS
ADVERTISE
MEDIA CENTRE
WHO'S ONLINE?
AFFILIATES
FAQ/CONTACT US
ABOUT US
BLOG
BOOKMARK US
HOME
Recommend this page to a friend.
Your Name:
Friends Name:
Friends Email:

This site uses cookies. For information on this, please see our privacy policy

About Contact Us Advertise Military Records New Members Terms Military Genealogy Sitemap